4 min to read
Woman Found Alive 26 Years After Vanishing as Toddler
Image: Youtube / E! News
A Disappearance Shrouded in Mystery
In a story that has captivated the nation, a woman who mysteriously vanished as a toddler has been found alive after an astonishing 26 years. Andrea Michelle Reyes, who went missing at just 23 months old from her father’s home in New Haven, Connecticut, has emerged back into the world that long thought she had been lost forever.
On that fateful day in 1999, Andrea disappeared from her father’s residence, a moment that would alter the lives of her family forever. Initial investigations led authorities to suspect that her non-custodial mother, Rosa Tenorio Andrea, had taken her. The mystery deepened when a felony warrant for custodial interference was issued later that year against Tenorio, and a second warrant followed in 2009. Despite the best efforts of multiple agencies, including the New Haven Police Department, the search for Andrea went cold, stranded in a sea of unanswered questions and painful uncertainties.
Investigative Persistence
For over two decades, Andrea’s name echoed through investigative corridors. Each day brought renewed hope and despair for her family. The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs) not only listed her as missing but went the extra mile by releasing five age-progression images between 2010 and 2014, depicting how she might look as she matured. Despite these efforts, the search continued to yield no results, and the trail grew colder, with officials believing she had been taken to Puebla, Mexico.
A Breakthrough
The resurgence of interest in Andrea’s case came in 2023 when the New Haven Police Department reopened her case. A breakthrough materialized when a woman, located in Mexico, reached out to Andrea’s father, asserting she might be his lost daughter. In a bid to verify this remarkable claim, investigators turned to Othram, a forensic lab known for its cutting-edge DNA testing capabilities.
Through the application of their KinSNP® Rapid Relationship Testing, DNA samples from the woman were compared to Andrea’s father’s profile. The outcome echoed like a shout of hope: it was confirmed—Andrea Reyes had been found, now a 27-year-old woman who has lived and grown in the shadows of a profoundly unsettling past.
Ongoing Pursuit of Justice
While this news paints a picture of reunion and relief, a shadow lingers overhead. The whereabouts of Rosa Tenorio Andrea remain undetermined, as police confirmed that an active arrest warrant for her still exists in the United States. Authorities suspect she may still be residing in Mexico, raising questions about accountability and justice for the actions that tore a family apart over two decades ago.
Andrea’s story carries substantial importance within Project 525, a collaborative initiative between Othram and RTI International. This project aims to resolve all juvenile missing persons cases listed in NamUs. Remarkably, her identification marks a significant milestone, making her the seventh person in Connecticut found through advanced DNA technology.
Police Chief Karl Jacobson expressed deep gratitude for the determined efforts of his team, citing that while investigative leads may have once grown scarce, no cold case is ever truly closed.
